Portugal news in English.

Subscribe

Audits Signed a Year Ago Found Lisbon's Glória, Lavra, Bica and Santa Justa Lifts on the Wrong Cables, and the Opposition Says Moedas Kept Them Quiet

CATIM's reports from October and November 2025 found cables meant for general lifting on all four lifts, and said the Lavra was not safe to run. Councillors only received them on Wednesday, and the Left Bloc wants the mayor to resign.

Audits Signed a Year Ago Found Lisbon's Glória, Lavra, Bica and Santa Justa Lifts on the Wrong Cables, and the Opposition Says Moedas Kept Them Quiet
The Bica funicular before its closure in September 2025 (illustrative). Photo: Casperbakker, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

External safety reports on four of Lisbon's historic lifts, written in the weeks after the Elevador da Glória crash killed 16 people on 3 September 2025, found that all four were running on cables not suited to carrying passengers. The reports, signed between 24 October and 25 November 2025, were only handed to opposition councillors on Wednesday 18 November 2026, after a television report on Monday revealed that they existed. The Left Bloc (BE) has called on Mayor Carlos Moedas to resign.

The inspections were carried out by the Centro de Apoio Tecnológico à Indústria Metalomecânica (CATIM, the Technological Support Centre for the Metalworking Industry) on the lifts run by Carris, the city's municipal transport company. Their content was reported on Wednesday by the Lusa news agency, as carried by ECO, and by RTP, which said it had seen the documents.

What the reports found

According to CATIM, the cables on the Glória, Lavra, Bica and Santa Justa lifts met the European standard EN 12385-4, which covers ropes for general lifting, when installations of this kind should use ropes meeting EN 12385-8. The findings, lift by lift:

  • Glória: the certificates for the cables Carris fitted in 2022 and 2024 said they must not be used with a swivel, yet the parts linking the cable to the cars had swivels. CATIM found "no evidence" that the last cable, fitted in 2024, had ever had a magnetic inductive inspection, the test that looks for damage inside a steel rope.
  • Lavra: the lift "did not meet the safety conditions to enter operation". A February 2023 report by the engineering institute ISQ, cited by CATIM, had already pointed to signs that put the cable's integrity in doubt. RTP notes that the Lavra uses the same type of cable as the Glória and ran until the day of the crash.
  • Bica: a series of nonconformities "requiring significant and urgent work". RTP reports severe corrosion on the Lavra and the Bica, including track supports that had lost all their load-bearing section, and says corrosion flagged on the Bica in 2022 had simply been painted over.
  • Santa Justa: the cable did not meet the right standard either, but CATIM found the joints were made in a way that kept the lift safe, since it hangs on 12 cables and the system is "more than redundant".
  • Graça funicular: the only one to have reopened, at the end of April 2026. CATIM found it compliant overall, with some failings in its emergency evacuation and rescue plan.

The Glória, Lavra, Bica and Santa Justa have been closed since the crash. Carris has said the Glória will come back as a new installation in 2029.

"Hidden for a year"

The opposition says the council's PSD, CDS-PP and IL leadership sat on the documents. The BE said the council stated on 3 December 2025 that the CATIM audit was "under way" when all four reports were finished. It also says that on 26 June 2026 Carris's board and the deputy mayor, Gonçalo Reis, told councillors that no report existed and that the audits had only been ordered in 2026. "They were hidden for a year. The conclusions are extremely serious," the party said, quoting Moedas's own definition of political responsibility: "when the politician knows and does not act".

Pedro Anastácio, a Socialist (PS) councillor, told RTP it was "an extremely serious failure" and a "deliberate attempt to hide information", arguing that the problems found in 2023 on the Lavra should on their own have stopped it running. João Ferreira, of the Communist Party (PCP), said councillors received the reports from the deputy mayor about an hour and a half before he spoke, after much insistence. "If Carlos Moedas did not know about these reports, he should have known. If he did, he withheld this information, and we need to understand why," he said. The reports we read carried no response from Moedas or Carris.

The investigations

The Ministério Público (Public Prosecution Service) is still investigating the crash and expects to close its inquiry by the end of the first quarter of 2027, once tests due this month are complete. The Gabinete de Prevenção e Investigação de Acidentes com Aeronaves e de Acidentes Ferroviários (GPIAAF, the air and rail accident investigation office) has pushed its final report back to the same date. Its preliminary report, in October 2025, had already found that the cable that gave way was not to Carris's own specification and was not certified for carrying people.

Funiculars and historic lifts now need authorisation from the transport regulator to run, under a decree published this month. Families of the victims are still pursuing compensation, and the insurer Fidelidade is disputing at least one claim.

Subscribe to The Portugal Brief

Portugal news in English, free by email. Choose your newsletters.

Already subscribed? Sign in