Teachers Press the Ministry to Investigate Physical Education Grades After Finding a 20 Out of 20 Is 2.66 Times More Common in Private Schools
Missão Escola Pública says 22.11 percent of private-school pupils got 20 in Physical Education in Years 11 and 12, against 8.31 percent in public schools, and wants the ministry to look into it.
A movement of state-school teachers has asked the education ministry to investigate how secondary pupils are graded in Physical Education (Educação Física), after finding that a top mark of 20 is far more common in private schools than in public ones. According to Público, on Monday, Missão Escola Pública (MEP) analysed the latest official data on internal grades in Years 11 and 12 and found that 22.11 percent of private-school pupils got 20 out of 20 in the subject, against 8.31 percent in public schools. The maximum mark, the group says, is 2.66 times more frequent in the private sector.
The complaint is about fairness between pupils. Grades on the Portuguese scale run from 0 to 20, and Physical Education is a three-year subject (disciplina trienal) on every academic secondary course, so its final mark is part of the secondary-school record on which pupils are compared. MEP also argues that the formula used to calculate the final secondary grade, in force since last year, should be changed, Público reports.
What the official data already shows
The gap is not new. The statistics office of the education ministry, the DGEEC, published a report in February 2025 on internal grades in the academic (científico-humanístico) secondary courses from 2017/18 to 2023/24. It found that:
- Physical Education was the three-year subject with the highest average in both sectors in 2023/24: 16.9 in public schools and 18.2 in private ones.
- In public schools its average rose from 15.7 in 2017/18 to 16.9 in 2023/24.
- Across all subjects, the average internal grade was 15.0 in public schools and 16.9 in private schools.
A follow-up DGEEC analysis of 2024/25, reported by RTP (Lusa) in August, found that 38 private schools, 35 percent of private schools teaching secondary level, gave a 19 or 20 in at least one subject to more than 30 percent of their pupils; 21 of them had done so every year since 2017/18. Among 483 public schools, only three reached that threshold. The DGEEC did not name the schools or say which subjects carried the highest marks.
Why internal grades weigh so much
Internal grades are set by each school; national exams are marked externally. Where a pupil sits a national exam in a subject they are studying, the final subject grade is 70 percent internal mark and 30 percent exam, according to the Directorate-General for Education (DGE). Subjects without a national exam rest entirely on the school's own assessment, which is why critics focus on them. The DGEEC data bears this out: annual Year 12 subjects, which are not externally assessed, carry the highest averages in both sectors, with 17.2 in public schools and more than 18 in private ones in 2024/25.
What it means for you
- If your child is in secondary school, ask the school how internal marks are set in each subject, including Physical Education, and how they compare with national exam results.
- You can compare your school's internal grades with its exam results on the ministry's own data; our guide to the 2025 school rankings explains how.
- This is a different measure from the Year 9 maths figures we reported on Saturday, when nearly three in ten pupils ended Year 9 with a maths fail.
We could not find a response from the Ministry of Education, Science and Innovation to MEP's request at the time of writing.