Ombudsman's Monitors Saw PSP Batons Hit Rossio Protesters on the Head and Spine, Including People Who Were Walking Away
The Ombudsman's report on the 1 November clearance of Lisbon's housing camp describes generalised baton use, blows to red-zone areas, inaudible warnings and a first-aider kept from an injured protester at first. The Interior Ministry says any breach must have legal consequences.
Monitors from the Provedora de Justiça (Ombudsman) watched the PSP clear the housing protest camp from Lisbon's Rossio before dawn on 1 November. They saw riot officers use their batons in a "generalised" way, sometimes on the head, the sternum and the spine, and on people who were not resisting or were already walking away. The Ombudsman published its 18-page report on Thursday.
The Ombudsman acts as Portugal's Mecanismo Nacional de Prevenção (MNP, National Preventive Mechanism) under the United Nations protocol against torture. Its team followed the march to the Rossio on 31 October, which it describes as peaceful. It stayed with the overnight camp until the police moved in at about 04:30, then followed the detainees to the PSP precinct at Martim Moniz.
What the monitors saw
Talks had failed: the police offered to leave the square alone if the tents were cut to five or six, and the protesters refused on principle. Seven rapid intervention teams first removed the tents, which were empty, while three flares and a firecracker were thrown at them. They then advanced with shields and, about 40 seconds later, began using batons across the line. Most blows were angled at lower-risk parts of the body, but some hit areas the PSP's own rules class as "red zones". A glass bottle and two cobblestones were thrown after the charge. The team could not see everything from its place behind the police line.
The dispersal warnings were clearly worded but inaudible to part of the crowd, and the organisers got no written record of the grounds for ending the protest, which the 1974 law on the right of assembly requires. Near Martim Moniz, officers at first resisted letting a first-aider reach an injured protester and gave way only after the monitors stepped in.
Six arrests, two accounts
Six people were arrested and taken to the precinct with plastic cable ties behind their backs. Three said they were assaulted during arrest, two of them by baton blows to the head, and the monitors photographed head injuries on two, with their consent. Paramedics treated three people within ten minutes; none needed hospital care. The officers recorded injuries only in writing, without photographs.
The PSP's own use-of-force report, handed over on 13 November, describes stones and Molotov-type devices thrown at officers. It says batons were aimed at arms and legs to overcome active resistance, and that no injuries could be established because "the suspects fled". The Ombudsman says this differs from what its team saw.
What the Ombudsman wants
The report makes 12 recommendations to the PSP's national command, among them:
- a visible name or number on the front of every special-unit uniform, since helmet numbers are only on the back;
- dispersal warnings everyone can hear;
- no baton blows on people who are not violent or are already under control;
- a specific inquiry into the incidents it saw, using video, use-of-force reports and medical records;
- photographs of detainees' injuries, and a record of every use of force at a crowd event, whether or not anyone is hurt.
The Ministério da Administração Interna (MAI, Interior Ministry) said in a statement carried by RTP that it would study the recommendations "with due attention" and that any breach of the use-of-force rules "should have the consequences provided for in law". It added that the Inspeção-Geral da Administração Interna (IGAI, the police inspectorate) and the Ministério Público (Public Prosecutor's Office) are already looking into the events. Observador reports that the ministry also reaffirmed its confidence in the PSP.
Police cleared the Rossio a third time that morning, after the Ombudsman's monitors had joined the march, and the camp later folded its tents. The full report is on the Ombudsman's website (in Portuguese).