Seven in 10 Buyers of Phone and Appliance Insurance Felt Short-Changed, and the Regulator Singles Out 31 Add-On Policies for Changes
The ASF reviewed 309 insurance products sold with goods and loans and found 31, from 21 insurers, needing action, with very low claims alongside high seller pay. Its survey found 61 percent of mortgage life insurance buyers lacked information or real choice.
Portugal's insurance regulator has singled out 31 add-on policies from 21 insurers as needing changes to protect customers. This is the cover sold alongside a new phone, a fridge or a home loan, and the regulator found products where customers almost never claim while the sellers take an unusually large cut. In a survey released the same day, about seven in ten people who bought insurance with a phone, appliance or other device said what they got back fell short of what they paid.
The findings were presented on Friday 20 November at the first consumer forum held by the Autoridade de Supervisão de Seguros e Fundos de Pensões (ASF, Insurance and Pension Funds Supervisory Authority) in Lisbon, an event the regulator billed on its own site as a debate on whether insurance products give consumers value for money. The figures below come from the speech by the ASF president, Gabriel Bernardino, and the survey results, as reported by Público. The ASF had not posted the speech on its website by mid-afternoon.
What the review found
The ASF examined 309 add-on insurance products. In 131 it found warning signs that justified a closer look, and it concluded that 31 of them, from 21 insurers, needed action to protect consumers. It did not name the products or the companies.
The clearest pattern, Bernardino said, was "very low levels of claims coexisting with particularly high distribution pay", above all in credit protection insurance and in cover sold with electronic equipment. He stressed that no single indicator proves a product is poor value, but that when several point the same way the regulator has a duty to dig deeper.
A "significant number" of insurers have formally committed to change their products, he said: their cover, claims handling, the information given to customers, internal oversight and the commissions paid to sellers. Some have stopped selling the product altogether, although the ASF did not say how many.
What customers said
- 43 percent said they understood the policy's conditions well or very well before signing.
- Only 30 percent rated the balance between price and benefits as good or very good; 45 percent called it reasonable and about 25 percent poor or very poor.
- For insurance bought with phones, household appliances and other devices, about seven in ten said the benefits fell short of what they expected for the price.
- For life insurance linked to a mortgage, 61 percent said they did not have enough information or full freedom to choose between the alternatives on the market.
- On retirement savings, 51 percent preferred a product balancing capital protection with growth, and about 28 percent put a capital guarantee first even at the cost of a lower return.
The answers were given voluntarily, so the ASF says they are indicative rather than a statistical sample of the population.
If you have a complaint
The ASF takes questions and complaints about insurers on its information line, (+351) 217 983 983, on weekdays from 09:00 to 16:00, through the form in the services area of asf.com.pt, or by email to [email protected]. In-person appointments are booked by phone.
Insurance has been in the news for homeowners this autumn: the ASF earlier urged households to check their policies and photograph storm damage after Storm Charles, and MPs this week voted to permanently end early-repayment fees on variable-rate mortgages.