Lisbon Council Invokes the Public Interest to Lift the Freeze on Its 59 Million Euro Plot Auction, and Says the 10 December Sale Goes Ahead
Lisbon City Council answered the citizens' injunction against its sale of ten municipal plots with a reasoned resolution under the administrative courts code and says the 10 December auction will proceed. The court has still to rule on its reasons.
Lisbon City Council (Câmara Municipal de Lisboa, CML) says its 10 December auction of ten municipal building plots "will go ahead", despite a court filing that had frozen the sale of eight of them. On Friday the council told the news agency Lusa that it had answered the citizens' injunction with a "resolução fundamentada" (a reasoned resolution) "that allows the public interest to be safeguarded", and that the sale would continue in order to fund more municipal investment, "especially in housing supply". The report was carried by RTP and Observador. Asked what reasons it had given the court, the council did not answer.
Hours earlier, former councillor José Sá Fernandes, one of the applicants, had told Lusa that the auction was suspended. "The court served notice on the municipality and so, at this moment, the auction is suspended," he said, RTP reported.
How the council can carry on
The injunction (providência cautelar, an urgent, provisional court measure) was filed on 6 November, a day after eight citizens brought a popular action (ação popular) at the Lisbon Administrative Court, as we reported on 14 November. The applicants include Sá Fernandes and former planning councillor Manuel Salgado, both elected for the Socialists.
The "reasoned resolution" is the device set out in Article 128 of the Code of Procedure in the Administrative Courts (CPTA). Once a public body is served with a request to suspend one of its decisions, it may not start or continue carrying it out, unless it sends the court a reasoned resolution recognising that a delay would be seriously harmful to the public interest. The same article says the execution is unlawful if the court rejects those reasons, and the applicants can ask the court to declare any acts carried out in the meantime ineffective. So the court still has to rule on the council's reasons and on the injunction itself, and the main case is still pending.
What the plots are, and the dispute
The ten plots have a combined base price of 59.2 million euros. The sale was proposed by the PSD, CDS-PP and IL administration and approved in July by the council and the Municipal Assembly, with Chega's support and every left-wing party voting against, according to Lusa.
Sá Fernandes argues the sale rests on "wrong assumptions" about how the land may be used. He says a plot on Rua Pardal Monteiro is earmarked for a housing cooperative in the council's own housing plan, and that sites on Rua Almirante Sarmento Rodrigues and Rua Emília Eduarda are in its affordable-rent programme. He also says the tender sets no condition for buyers to build at controlled cost, contrary to what deputy mayor Gonçalo Reis has said, and that some land is part of the municipal ecological structure.
Mayor Carlos Moedas told the Municipal Assembly on Tuesday that with the end of EU recovery plan funds the sale is needed to keep building homes. "Money does not fall from the sky," he said, adding that those trying to stop it "want less housing".
What it means for residents
- For now the council is treating the 10 December auction as going ahead; bids were due by 4 December under the published notice.
- A buyer could still face legal uncertainty: if the court rejects the council's reasons, steps taken in the meantime can be declared ineffective.
- The case turns on whether city-owned land should be sold for cash to fund housing, or kept for cooperative and affordable-rent homes. Moedas is also pushing a metropolitan housing company with a bank of vacant land.